Sydney Weather - Mostly sunny
Now
Max
Sydney, NSW
Mostly sunny

Editor's Pick

Plant 'telepathy' breakthrough
WE can't hear it, but scientists are finding that in the apparently silent world of plants, a whole ...
Wet weeks change grain game
THE DYNAMIC in the Australian grains industry has altered markedly in the past fortnight, with good ...
Wool kicks another 18c
THE wool market has continued its upwards climb, with the Eastern Market Indicator (EMI) hitting a s...
NSW Boarding School Expo
  • Download The Land eReader -left
    Download The Land eReader - right

Latest Comments

light grey arrow To protect against inappropriate content, this is a moderated discussion and...
light grey arrow Sin bin for Bushie Bill for life. You can not allow that sort of hatred to...
Win a Casterton Kelpie
YOU could win a Casterton Kelpie - the prize pup “Go Getta Law” is valued up to $3000. To enter, rea...
Ausmectin Beef Weeks
THE Ausmectin Southern and Northern Beef Weeks offer cattlemen and women an unsurpassed opportunity ...
Farming Small Areas eEdition
Read the latest issue of the Farming Small Areas magazine online.
Horse Deals May issue out now
Horses for sale plus hours of great reading.
 Opinion  light grey arrow  Blogs  light grey arrow  Canberra Comment  light grey arrow  Ag spared slashing, but still no vision 
CONVERSATIONS
Comments on this article
The land comments
1

Ag spared slashing, but still no vision

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
John Cobb.

John Cobb.

SOME agricultural industry analysts would suggest the Shadow Federal Agriculture Minister John Cobb may have woken up on Wednesday morning with a bit of egg on his face after the Federal government’s budget announcement Tuesday night.

The government’s 2012-13 budget forecast announced some sensible measures for agriculture and avoided the type of pre-budget fiscal carnage and mayhem that had some sectors of the economy like agriculture, trembling in fear.

Funding for critical programs like Caring for our Country and creation of a new biosecurity facility, driven by recommendations from the Beale Review, albeit over seven years, ensured agriculture wasn’t smashed beyond recognition.

The final budget failed to accurately reflect the ferocious sentiment expressed by the Shadow Minister in the lead up to Tuesday’s announcement, where he predicted savage budget cuts would take place at the hands of the Treasurer’s rabid hatchet that would potentially cruel the agricultural industry and render the sector collateral damage in the Labor government’s rabid pursuit of a budget surplus, to achieve a desperately desired political win.

The end result was quite different than those words may have led observers to believe but that’s only just for the short term.

Overall it was still a mediocre effort at best and is nothing for the ALP to get too cocky about.

Federal Treasurer Wayne Swan produced a modest $1.5 billion surplus in the final budget papers and as the National Farmers Federation said, it extrapolated to an average return for the sector that had a couple of good wins.

An almost patronising result one would say; if you lived outside of Sydney, Melbourne, Perth, Adelaide or any other big city.

In reality, after cutting out the spin and hype and smashing some of the budget mirrors and clearing the smoke, the Labor budget lacked provision for the longer term.

It failed to carry forward the type of government backing needed to build ongoing confidence, with the smart investment in R&D and productivity gains that industry members would prefer to see take place over a modest surplus.

It really only gave Mr Swan an opportunity to chirp for a short time about the ALP’s clever financial management skills, while outside the party room the Thomson and Slipper affairs continue to dominate headlines.

Notably the Treasurer only mentioned agriculture once in the budget lock-up media conference, on Tuesday afternoon.

Even the words of Greens leader Christine Milne reflected a similar sentiment about a modest result for the short term that lacked any longer term vision for agriculture; in particular around investments to achieve productivity gains in a land and water constrained environment.

Other industry analysts relayed the same kind of thinking; that it was an average budget result that didn’t totally smash agriculture today and was “all about the surplus”.

However, the common theme was about the budget’s concerning lack of vision for tomorrow’s world with future food security underpinning most people’s strategic thinking.

And in this regard, Mr Cobb’s predictions remained as strong as ever Wednesday morning when he refused to concede that he’d been over the top with his pre-budget commentary.

Rather than having egg on his face, he was still dining out on the ALP’s inability to comprehend the rural sector’s machinations and lauded the future fate of an agricultural portfolio managed by a timid and at times misguided Minister in Joe Ludwig.

After all, the government’s lack of vision and foresight and broader understanding of the interconnectivity associated with rural issues and communities is one of Mr Cobb’s main talking points and that of other Nationals and rural Liberals who either farm themselves or actually live in the bush.

Mr Cobb may not express his views as clearly and as eloquently as others can in public and may come across like a bull in a china shop at times due to his frustration at what he sees taking place in the ALP camp in this term of government.

But there’s little doubt he clearly sees the death of thousand cuts taking place for his beloved farming sector and rural Australia – right before his eyes - and that frustration appears to be growing by the day.

One can imagine that, rather than dealing with the latest budget night, he’d have preferred to have been waking up after an election with a comprehensive democratic result delivered by the Australian people and to begin making some real and serious changes.

But he can just keep dreaming for now and hope reality doesn’t bite too hard for the sector in future.

Page:
single page
Date: Newest first | Oldest first

READER COMMENTS

OH please the Nationals are only interested in pandering to big agricorps, the chemical industries and mining sectors, they have completely left family farmers and betray them at every turn. Where were they in when the previous government was in and they supposedly they had a chance at doing something? No where to be seen. They are a useless party now and should just rebadge them selves as city Liberals.
Posted by Max, 24/05/2012 7:45:52 AM
Canberra Comment
Rural Press Canberra bureau chief Colin Bettles tackles the big national rural and agricultural issues and ensures the hard questions are asked about how policies and decisions will impact remote and rural Australians.

Cropping

REPEATED application of herbicides with the same mode of action (MOA) is the single greatest risk factor for the evolution of herbicide resistance.
REPEATED application of herbicides with the same mode of action (MOA) is the single greatest risk factor...
MORE than 70 growers and grain traders have registered their interest in a potential class action against independent grain marketing company Emerald Grain.
MORE than 70 growers and grain traders have registered their interest in a potential class action against...
WILLAURA district farmer Anthony Evans is well on track with his cropping program after rain in the past fortnight delivered more rain than he had received for the entire year prior to that.
WILLAURA district farmer Anthony Evans is well on track with his cropping program after rain in the past...

Machinery

PARKLANDS have released a new wood chipper just in time for the colder months.
PARKLANDS have released a new wood chipper just in time for the colder months.
AGCO Australia has merged with the GSI Group - a global supplier of grain storage, material handling, conditioning and drying solutions.

Wool

FOR the third week running the wool market has gained ground with the Eastern Market Indicator this week closing 16 cents ahead at 1038 cents a kilograms.
FOR the third week running the wool market has gained ground with the Eastern Market Indicator this week...
THE wool market has continued its upwards climb, with the Eastern Market Indicator (EMI) hitting a six-week high yesterday of 1040c a kilogram.
THE wool market has continued its upwards climb, with the Eastern Market Indicator (EMI) hitting a...

Livestock

LIVESTOCK industry groups are seeking to confirm media reports that Indonesia has lifted its beef import quota volume from Australia to meet increased demand this year, ahead...
FOR the third week running the wool market has gained ground with the Eastern Market Indicator this week closing 16 cents ahead at 1038 cents a kilograms.
FOR the third week running the wool market has gained ground with the Eastern Market Indicator this week...
A TOTAL of 145 bulls sold to gross $435,500 - with the top price bull sold for $10,000 - at the 14th Annual Ponderosa Sale.
A TOTAL of 145 bulls sold to gross $435,500 - with the top price bull sold for $10,000 - at the 14th...

Agribusiness

AUSTRALIA’S first National Food Plan, first flagged by Labor ahead of the 2010 election, was launched in Brisbane this morning after almost two years in the pipeline.
AUSTRALIA’S first National Food Plan, first flagged by Labor ahead of the 2010 election, was launched in...
LANDMARK has snapped up Viterra Australia's agriproducts and wool businesses following 18 months of negotiations.

Horticulture

THE Pollination Program is warning Australia’'s apple and pear industries to take more notice of the lessons learnt in New Zealand, where the invasion of the Varroa mite has caused significant damage to the beekeeping industry and subsequently impacted the production of pollination reliant crops.
THE Pollination Program is warning Australia’'s apple and pear industries to take more notice of the...
Fruit Growers Tasmania will host over 200 delegates at their annual May conference which starts in Hobart later this week.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...