Error in Snowy soils carbon report

16 Jul, 2010 10:36 AM

THE figures have changed, but Sydney University’s message that highly fertile soils may be capable of sequestering more methane than cattle produce hasn’t.

The University has acknowledged a “transcription error” in a report published by Rural Press last year, which suggested that certain Snowy Mountains soils were capable of oxidising (and effectively rendering climate-neutral) 8750 kilograms of methane per hectare per year.

At the time, Professor Mark Adams, Dean of Sydney University’s Faculty of Agriculture, Food and Natural Resources, told Rural Press that grazing of cattle on these soils was “easily methane-neutral and may even offset cow-methane from other parts of the landscape”.

The sums altered radically when it was discovered that micrograms of methane had been wrongly transcribed as milligrams, a much larger unit of measure.

Dr Robert Simpson, a post-doctoral research fellow who supplied the corrected values, said the methane oxidation rate measured by University researchers is actually 8.75 kilograms per hectare per year.

“We still feel this is a very high methane (CH4) sink in a global context, and can offset significant percentages of enterprise-scale CH4 emissions where grazing intensity is low or seasonal and soils have a high intrinisic ability to oxidise atmospheric CH4,” Dr Simpson said.

Even with the corrected figures, the methane oxidation rate in high country soils is only known to be exceeded by pristine New Zealand forest.

Prof. Adams affirmed that despite the significant rescaling of the figures, certain high country soils oxidised methane at sufficient rates to fully offset enteric methane production in low intensity grazing systems.

He also restated his belief that any accounting approach to greenhouse gas emissions needs to properly account for “sinks” as well as “sources”.

In a paper using the correct figures, Dr Simpson, Prof. Adams and Dr Tina Bell of the University of Melbourne did some sums on a hypothetical 1000 hectare high country grazing area made up of 49 per cent woodlands, 49 per cent grassland and two per cent bog.

Grazing by 200 head of cattle for six months of the year across this area would produce about 5.4 tonnes of methane per year.

Methane oxidation rates in soil, according to University measurements, would total about 7.6 tonnes across the 1000 hectares, ensuring that the grazing emissions would be clearly offset.

“Clearly not all systems will have a net sequestration of CH4, however these data underscore that any quantification of CH4 production from ruminants for the purposes of accounting cannot be calculated as a gross number,” the authors said.

Date: Newest first | Oldest first


Ian Mott
19/07/2010 9:40:04 AM, on The Land

Gee wiz, whats a thousand fold error to a bunch of climatards on the gravy train? And here we go again with the same incompetent crapola that leaves out the background methane from termites etc in the forested area. When land is cleared for pasture this natural source of methane emissions is reduced as the stock methane increases. But instead of comparing the net change, these intellectual sloths take the easy way out and report on the gross figure. And surprise, surprise, we get yet another piece of green "rent-a-finding" that demonises farming and farmers. Add the reduced 'natural' emissions back into the equation and we have the usual dreary much ado about sweet FA.
19/07/2010 2:14:55 PM, on The Land

Sloppy error. Nonetheless, the fact that soils oxidise methane at all is good news. I always wondered where all the methane went. It had to be recycled some how or life on earth would have been still born.


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *


light grey arrow
Great image, great initiative. The sight of sheep trotting down Savile Row would have stopped
light grey arrow
Yes Donut and the CFMEU are going to remember the name Dyson Heydon for a long long time. If I
light grey arrow
Xenophon is on the money. Even if we export more barley, beef, etc, do the pro TPP puppets