Don't blame Labor for vitriol: Swan

31 Dec, 2012 06:35 AM
Wayne Swan.
'I don't concede that the government has been behind personal attacks.
Wayne Swan.

THE Gillard government bears no responsibility for the negative and vitriolic tone of the political debate in 2012, says Treasurer Wayne Swan.

He admits the ''scrappy'' political year turned many voters off politics but denies the government contributed to bitter partisanship that defined it.

''I don't concede that the government has been behind personal attacks,'' he said. ''We want to have a policy discussion based on the facts, not on the aggressive negativity, particularly the likes of which we've seen from Tony Abbott … to say that's a personal attack on Tony Abbott, given the events of last year, I find quite extraordinary.''

This year, Prime Minister Julia Gillard labelled Opposition Leader Mr Abbott a misogynist, Health Minister Nicola Roxon said he had an ''issue with capable women'', and Mr Swan called him a ''policy weakling'' and a ''thug when it comes to personal attacks''.

Climate Change Minister Greg Combet called Mr Abbott a ''wrecker'' and said everything the Opposition Leader had told the public about carbon pricing was ''complete bullshit''.

But Mr Swan denied the government was culpable in helping to set the low tone of what has been labelled the nastiest political year in memory.

''You've got to be kidding me. The negativity in policy and personal attacks have all been from Abbott. I mean, for god's sake, these are the people who are now hung out to dry for their activities in terms of Mr Ashby and company,'' he said in reference to the Federal Court finding that the Liberal National Party-endorsed candidate, Mal Brough, conspired with James Ashby to end the political career of former speaker Peter Slipper.

Despite the finding, Mr Abbott has since expressed his full confidence in Mr Brough.

''I'm a little surprised at the notion that there is some sort of equivalence in terms of the negativity going on … the Prime Minister in particular in the face of enormous negative attack and enormous denigration performed superbly,'' Mr Swan said. ''Too often that gets brushed aside in some sort of notion that it was some sort of two-way process.''

The Treasurer pledged to haul the political debate to positive territory in 2013, saying it was his ''New Year's resolution'' to ignore ''glass-half-empty'' naysayers. ''My hope is to have a very, very strong policy debate … about the big reforms we need to set up [in] Australia for the future. That's where the government is coming from.''

Mr Swan said the government this year instituted ''one of the biggest reforms for the future of Australia'' - carbon pricing - in the face of ''vicious opposition, not just from the Liberals but from large sections of industry''.

''That showed the government's fortitude and commitment to policy, because what's got lost since the carbon pricing came in is how big a reform that had been.''

He also defended his surplus backdown, made a fortnight ago when he announced a $3.9 billion shortfall in revenue in the first four months of the financial year. He argued the surplus announcement should not be seen as a ''loosening of the purse strings'', and that the government had delivered record low interest rates that were helping business and families.

''In the circumstances of the international volatility, it would have been irresponsible to cut deeper or further during this period, because that would just endanger jobs and growth.''

Mr Swan rejected suggestions the mining tax had been unsuccessful, pointing to a fall in commodity prices, and nominated the key policy battlegrounds of 2013 as education, the National Disability Insurance Scheme, industrial relations and the National Broadband Network. ''We would love to get on with them in an environment which wasn't characterised by the excessive negativity we saw last year [2012].''

Date: Newest first | Oldest first


1/01/2013 10:38:26 AM

What a joke this little person and his totally dishonest, incompetant Govt is. They have reduced the Aust Parliament to a sordid laughable soap opera. Any decent minister would have resigned after the embarrasing admission that there wouldn't be a surplus after being so adamant that there would be one. In the last year, this Govt has shown us just what vitriol is, and the sooner the election is called the sooner we can throw these clowns out.
1/01/2013 11:06:03 AM

What a load off BULL SH** they are the problem.
Loc Hey
2/01/2013 7:24:17 AM

There is a strong reverse relationship between commitment to the Labor party and high intelligence. Why should intelligent people have to put up with the inadequacies of the stupid.
Bushie Bill
2/01/2013 12:55:26 PM

Good to see you finally figured out how to operate your Spellchecker, Locco. Congratulations. A big achievement for you so early in the new year, eh? Do you think you will have any more wins this year? However, you do surprise me Locco. You, of all people, talking about inverse relationships with intelligence. How bold! Talk about leading with your chin!
6/01/2013 8:12:06 AM

Good point Loc Hey, & you've snookered BSBill as he can only deliver his usual critical smart-arse comments. Swan is a turkey, always has been, always will be.
Bushie Bill
6/01/2013 2:24:00 PM

It seems, Graz old son, your only contribution is to regurgitate ill-informed redneck puerile propaganda served up by a lifetime of talking to too many sheep. I also notice you and Locco have not mustered enough grey-matter concentration to actually respond to my comment. Snookered you say, eh?
Loc Hey
7/01/2013 9:23:32 AM

Hey Graz, you forgot to mention Bushie Bill is a turkey too. Seems you have got him a little hot under the collar. Did you actually make a comment Bushie? I thought you were just rambling on with your usual nonsensical irrelevant rubbish. Thats comes with a lifetime of talking to too many turkeys.
8/01/2013 11:43:27 AM

Doesn't hurt to give his cage a little rattle occasionally, Loc Hey. Makes him really nasty, & kind of funny in a way.


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *


light grey arrow
Look, I'm pretty dumb to all of this argument, but here is a though, Canberra real estate is
light grey arrow
So QLD LNP states everything is the fault of the MDB Plan and the MDBA. They refuse to accept
light grey arrow
What a pity that the GM brigade didn't come up with frost tolerant crops. I've been told they