Ambiguous rules hurt Lachlan irrigators' confidence

Lachlan irrigators say allocations contradict water sharing plan

News
Tom Green, Lachlan Park, Forbes said ambiguity surrounding how water was allocated was hurting irrigator confidence in the Lachlan Valley. Photo: Daniel Pedersen

Tom Green, Lachlan Park, Forbes said ambiguity surrounding how water was allocated was hurting irrigator confidence in the Lachlan Valley. Photo: Daniel Pedersen

Aa

Lachlan irrigators have had their carryover restricted, but high security is still being allocated.

Aa

Like a middle child, when it comes to water politics central NSW is somewhat overlooked, but in the Lachlan Valley irrigators are facing their own set of challenges.

Inflows to Wyangala Dam have been critically low since 2017 and it has been almost three years since general security water licence holders were issued an allocation.

And the Department of Planning, Industry and Environment (DPIE) has restricted general security carryover water - initially by 43 per cent last July, but that was cut in half again last week.

However, high security water has continued to be allocated, albeit reduced to a 70pc opening allocation this year and 87pc last water year.

Irrigators in the Lachlan Valley have argued the continued allocation of high security water, while general security carryover remains restricted, contradicts the rules laid out in the valley's Water Resource Plan.

Tom Green, Lachlan Park, Forbes, is chairman of irrigator group, Lachlan Valley Water and runs a prime lamb operation alongside his cropping business.

He has had to reduce his breeding stock by about 80pc because of the recent years of drought and lack of water available to irrigate his lucerne crops for feed.

Methodology for allocations "policy on the run" 

He said irrigators were concerned by the methodology the DPIE was using to allocate water.

"The rules say you shouldn't make a new allocation to a licence without taking into account general security carryover.

"But, you can't have a lower priority licence overtake a high priority licence, so there's been a conflict between new high security allocations and the restrictions to general security carryover."

He said it appeared the DPIE was creating different systems every year to work out the share of water.

"I think there needs to be good guidelines in place so people can see what the restrictions will be if a forecasted scenario occurs, that way there are no surprises, the surprises are what hurts confidence."

Nick Turner, chairman of Lachlan Valley private irrigation corporation, Jemalong Irrigation, said with the restrictions to carryover, it was unlikely they would be able to provide an irrigation run this season.

Mr Turner described the allocation of water in the valley as "policy on the run."

"It appears that the allocations haven't been made in accordance with the rules of the water sharing plan," Mr Turner said.

"They've gone and used their own interpretation of the rules so there's uncertainty and ambiguity about how the water will be allocated and shared between high security and general security carryover both now and in the future.

"This is negatively impacting irrigator confidence."

Wyangala inflows dropped by almost 90 per cent in a year

Lachlan Valley Water executive officer Mary Ewing explained that the chance of carryover being restricted increased when they went from a very wet period to a very dry period quickly.

"2016/2017 was a very wet year in the Lachlan so people went into that year with a lot of water in their accounts," she said.

"In 2016/2017 there was 1,495,000 megalitres of inflows to Wyangala but in 2017/2018 it fell to about 165,000ML."

She said the Lachlan also operated continuous accounting, meaning although you have an account limit there is no time limit for how long you can carry the water over for.

"People wanted more control over how they managed their water over a period of time," Ms Ewing said.

"They want to operate in a more consistent way than boom, bust, otherwise its hard because you need staff one year, you don't need them the next."

She said irrigators realised when they supported continuous accounting, in the 2004 Water Sharing Plan, that there was a risk that general security carryover would not always be deliverable.

"The Lachlan is a long river, it requires 180,000 megalitres to run the river every year before any water is delivered," Ms Ewing said.

"On top of that to provide high security, town water, stock and domestic, and deliver that, takes another 53,000ML. Your normal operation for a year is 233,000ML."

She said people had expected the high security allocation to be lower this year and the share between high security and general security carryover was an ongoing issue.

However, she said low reliability of general security water in the Lachlan is nothing new.

"People have been through some large extremes over the last 20 years," Ms Ewing said.

"Through the millennium drought the Lachlan went through a period of very low availability of water, so I think that's why people who need reliable water, like permanent plantings, have high security or groundwater.

"But since widespread trading came into play it's not only permanent plantings who hold high security, there is a lot of water moving around."

DPIE say high security trumps general security carryover

A spokesperson for the DPIE responded to The Land's inquiry about this issue saying water allocations this year, as in every year, have been shared across high security and general security licences in accordance with the Water Sharing Plans and the Water Management Act 2000.

"The Act mandates that high security licences, like town water, be given higher priority for access to water over general security licences," the spokesperson said.

"For the 2020/21 water year there is around 97 gigalitres of general security account water, including 67GL already 'frozen' in accounts in 2019/20 and 30GL still 'active.'"

Have you signed up to The Land's free daily newsletter? Register below to make sure you are up to date with everything that's important to NSW agriculture.

Aa

From the front page

Sponsored by